Revista Científica UDO Agrícola Volumen 7. Número 1. Año 2007. Páginas: 22-28
Evaluation and heritability studies of local Lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.)
cultivars from south-west Nigeria
Evaluación y estudios de heredabilidad
de algunos cultivares locales de Phaseolus lunatus (L.) del sudoeste de Nigeria
Sikirat Remi
AKANDE and Morufat Oloruntoyin
BALOGUN
Institute
of Agricultural Research and Training Obafemi Awolowo University, Moor Plantation, P.M.B. 5029, Ibadan,
Nigeria. E-mail:
remiajibade2002@yahoo.com Corresponding author
Received: 08/15/2007 |
First reviewing ending: 10/26/2007 |
First review received: 11/30/2007 |
Accepted: 12/14/2007 |
ABSTRACT
Seven local Lima
bean cultivars were evaluated at Ile-Ife in the humid rainforest environment of
south western Nigeria for two years. A randomized complete block design with three
replications was used each year. Data were subjected to analysis of variance,
Pearson correlation and stepwise multiple regression analyses. Heritability
estimates of 10 agronomic characters evaluated were also determined.
Significant year and cultivar effects were observed for most of the characters.
Seed yield ha-1 varied from 289.14 to
Key words: Lima beans, evaluation,
correlation, heritability estimates, seed yield.
RESUMEN
Se evaluaron siete cultivares locales de Phaseolus lunatus (L.)
en ambiente de selva lluviosa húmeda del sudoeste de Nigeria durante dos años.
Se utilizó un diseño de bloques completos al azar con tres repeticiones en cada
año. Los datos evaluados se analizaron mediante el análisis de varianza y los
análisis de correlación de Pearson y de regresión múltiple paso a paso. También
se determinaron las estimaciones de heredabilidad de
10 caracteres agronómicos. Se observaron efectos significativos para la
interacción años x cultivar para la mayoría de los caracteres. El rendimiento
de semilla/ha varió de
Palabras claves:
Phaseolus lunatus,
rendimiento de semilla, caracteres agronómicos, correlación, heredabilidad
INTRODUCTION
Lima
bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.) originated
in tropical America. Details of the origin and distributions of this crop have
been described by various authors (Kay, 1979; Rachie et al., 1980; Lyman et al., 1985; Smart 1990). Following introduction to the various
ecological zones, Lima bean underwent considerable adaptation and hybridization
to produce the various local strains that exist in the different regions of
America, Europe, Asia and Africa (Esquivel et
al., 1990; Nwokolo, 1996). The USA is the world largest producer of lima
beans followed by Malagasy and Peru.
In
Nigeria, Lima bean is cultivated mainly for the dry seeds. Like other grain
legumes, it is an important source of vegetable protein and it also improves
soil fertility. It is well adapted to
the humid rainforest environment of southern Nigeria. Despite the great
potential of this crop, it is highly under-utilized in the country and it has
not received much attention in term of crop improvement and so local cultivars
are still being grown by the farmers. Lima bean has not received the benefit of
intensive research programme as devoted to cowpea and
soybean (Lyman et al., 1985). It is
cultivated in only about 4% land area devoted to grain legumes production in
south west Nigeria with no improved technology targeted towards the production
of the crop and so yield is low. It is
usually intercropped with cassava, maize, yam, cocoyam and pepper. It is mainly
produced for consumption as only about 35% of the grain produced is sold (Saka et al.,
2004). There is therefore, urgent need
for the improvement of this crop.
For
the improvement of any crop, knowledge of the relations among various
characters with seed yield is essential in order to find appropriate selection
criteria. Also type of selection to be done and progress from selection for a
particular character depends in part on the magnitude of heritability
estimate. This is because the expected
response under selection is a function of heritability, variation and selection
intensity. Quite often characters are correlated and selection for one
character may lead to negative or positive response in the other
character. This response can be
predicted if the correlation and the heritability of the characters are known (Morakinyo, 1996). The objectives of this work therefore,
were to evaluate the performance of seven local lima bean cultivars from
south-west Nigeria and to study the correlation coefficients among 10 agronomic
characters of the crop and their heritability as an aid to improving the crop.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Seven local Lima
bean cultivars were evaluated for seed yield and nine other agronomic
characters at Ile-Ife, Nigeria for two years (2005 and 2006). Ile-Ife lies within the humid rainforest zone
of south west Nigeria (7◦ 22′ N, 3◦ 33′ E,
The
seeds were sown in June of each year under rain fed conditions. The source of
the seven Lima bean local cultivars evaluated are presented in Table
Table 1. Source
of the seven lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.) cultivars evaluated at Ile-Ife, Nigeria
in 2005 and 2006. |
||
Cultivars |
Seed colour |
Source
(State) |
NSWP83 |
Grey |
Ondo |
NSWP9 |
Brown |
Ekiti |
NSWP52 |
White |
Ekiti |
NSWP51 |
Speckled
brown |
Oyo |
NSWP89 |
Brown |
Ondo |
NSWP46 |
Brown |
Oyo |
NSWP53 |
Brown |
Ekiti |
To
reduce border effects, data were recorded only from the three central rows of
the five row plots. At maturity, measurement for each trait was carried out on
five plants per plot and the mean value used for the analysis. Data collected
were: number of days to 50% flowering, mid leaflet surface area (the middle
leaflet of the trifoliate leaf), number of main branches per plant at the first
effective branch, branching height (length of stem from the ground level to the
base of effective branch). Inter-nodal length (distance between the third and
the fourth nodes), pod weight per plant, pod length, number of seeds per pod
and 100-seed weight. Harvesting of the pods was carried out in December of each
of the two years. All pods of the middle two rows of each plot were harvested
together, dried and threshed to determine seed yield per plot from which seed
yield per hectare was estimated.
The data were subjected to analysis
of variance, and means were separated using Duncan Multiple Range test. Pearson
correlation and stepwise multiple regression analyses were also carried out to
determine the main yield components for Lima bean. Broad sense heritability
estimates were calculated using the variance components derived from the
analysis of variance.
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
The
average values of the vegetative and reproductive characters of the lima bean
cultivars in 2005 and 2006 are shown in Tables 2 and 3. The cultivars varied
significantly for all the characters except for the number of main branches.
Cultivar means across years show that branching height varied between 7 and
Table 2. Average values of
vegetative characters of seven Lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.) local cultivars evaluated
at Ile-Ife, Nigeria in 2005 and 2006. |
||||||||
|
Cultivars † |
|||||||
Years |
NSWP83 |
NSWP9 |
NSWP52 |
NSWP51 |
NSWP89 |
NSWP46 |
NSWP53 |
YM |
|
Branches per plant |
|||||||
2005 |
4.00 |
4.00 |
4.00 |
4.00 |
4.67 |
5.00 |
3.00 |
4.09a |
2006 |
3.00 |
3.00 |
3.00 |
2.33 |
3.00 |
3.00 |
3.00 |
2.91b |
CM |
3.50 |
3.50 |
3.50 |
3.17 |
3.84 |
4.00 |
3.00 |
|
|
Branching height (cm) |
|||||||
2005 |
9.00bc |
9.00bc |
10.33b |
13.00a |
8.00c |
8.50bc |
13.00a |
10.12a |
2006 |
8.00b |
8.00b |
8.00b |
7.00bc |
6.00c |
6.50c |
11.00a |
7.79b |
CM |
8.50cd |
8.50cd |
9.17bc |
10.00b |
7.00e |
7.50de |
12.00a |
|
|
Inter nodal length (cm) |
|||||||
2005 |
7.33bc |
7.33bc |
6.33bc |
9.00a |
8.67ab |
4.00d |
10.83a |
7.64 |
2006 |
6.17bc |
8.50ab |
5.00c |
8.00ab |
7.33abc |
5.17c |
9.47a |
7.09 |
CM |
6.75cd |
7.92bc |
5.67de |
8.50ab |
8.00ab |
4.59e |
10.15a |
|
|
Mid leaflet surface area (cm2) |
|||||||
2005 |
55.00d |
69.00b |
56.00cd |
59.00cd |
70.00b |
83.00a |
64.00c |
65.14 |
2006 |
53.00c |
62.00b |
50.00c |
50.00c |
66.00a |
62.00b |
53.00c |
56.57 |
CM |
54.00e |
65.50c |
53.00e |
54.50e |
68.00b |
72.00a |
58.50b |
|
† Cultivar means (CM) on the
same row followed by different letters are significantly different at 0.05
probability level according to Duncan Multiple Range test. For each trait, year means (YM) followed by different letters are
significantly different at 0.05 probability level according to Duncan
Multiple Range test. |
Table 3. Average values of
the reproductive characters of seven Lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.) local cultivars evaluated
at Ile-Ife, Nigeria in 2005 and 2006. |
||||||||
Cultivars † |
||||||||
Years |
NSWP83 |
NSWP9 |
NSWP52 |
NSWP51 |
NSWP89 |
NSWP46 |
NSWP53 |
YM |
|
Days to 50% flowering |
|||||||
2005 |
85.00b |
83.33b |
84.00b |
83.00b |
90.00a |
89.67b |
85.00b |
85.71a |
2006 |
82.67b |
80.00c |
83.33b |
82.00b |
86.00a |
87.33a |
86.00a |
83.91b |
CM |
83.84bc |
81.67d |
83.67bc |
82.50cd |
88.00a |
88.50a |
85.50b |
|
|
Pod length (cm) |
|||||||
2005 |
6.50bc |
5.00c |
7.00b |
6.00bc |
7.00b |
7.00b |
11.00a |
7.07a |
2006 |
6.00b |
4.00c |
6.00b |
5.50bc |
5.00bc |
6.20b |
10.00a |
6.10b |
CM |
6.25b |
4.50c |
6.50b |
5.75b |
6.00b |
6.60b |
10.50a |
|
|
Seeds per pod |
|||||||
2005 |
4.00a |
2.00b |
3.00ab |
3.00ab |
3.00ab |
4.00a |
3.00ab |
3.14a |
2006 |
3.67a |
2.00c |
2.00c |
2.00c |
3.00b |
2.67b |
3.00b |
2.62b |
CM |
3.84a |
2.00c |
2.50bc |
2.50bc |
3.00ab |
3.34ab |
3.00ab |
|
|
100 seed weight (g) |
|||||||
2005 |
28.52c |
22.21d |
31.46b |
28.62c |
31.69b |
28.66c |
71.21a |
34.62 |
2006 |
25.37d |
21.37e |
29.90b |
26.81cd |
30.83b |
27.70c |
67.40a |
32.75 |
CM |
26.95d |
21.79e |
30.68b |
27.72cd |
31.26b |
28.18d |
69.31a |
|
|
Pod weight (g) |
|||||||
2005 |
55.77b |
23.03e |
38.18d |
18.06f |
43.45c |
20.91ef |
83.19a |
40.08a |
2006 |
61.34a |
19.47d |
31.92c |
15.66e |
21.16d |
19.55d |
42.36b |
30.21b |
CM |
58.56b |
21.25d |
35.05c |
16.86e |
32.31c |
20.23d |
62.78a |
|
|
Seed yield (Kg ha-1) |
|||||||
2005 |
1112.5b |
446.47e |
625.80d |
302.53g |
750.70c |
361.50f |
1654.09a |
750.51a |
2006 |
1059.04b |
337.58f |
554.33c |
275.75g |
375.51d |
347.78e |
1063.39a |
573.34b |
CM |
1085.77b |
392.03e |
590.07c |
289.14g |
563.11d |
354.64f |
1358.74a |
|
† Cultivar means (CM) on the
same row followed by different letters are significantly different at 0.05
probability level according to Duncan Multiple Range test. For
each trait, year means (YM) followed by different letters are significantly
different at 0.05 probability level according to Duncan Multiple Range test. |
Number
of days to 50% flowering ranged from 81.67 to 88.50 with NSWPP9 and NSWP46
being earliest and latest to flower respectively. Pod length ranged from
The
cultivar NSWP53 had the highest grain yield and high values for other
characters except mid leaflet surface area.
Hence, this cultivar would be incorporated into breeding project for
further improvement. Apart from the two cultivars (NSPW83 and NSPW53) which had
grain yields of above
Significant year effect was observed for all
the characters evaluated except for number of seeds per pod. The results
indicate that changes in environmental conditions between the two years influenced
the performance of the cultivars (Tables 2 and 3). The cultivars flowered earlier in 2006 with
an average value of 83.91 compared with 85.71 recorded in 2005. Higher values
were also recorded for all other characters when evaluated in 2005 (Tables 2
and 3). For example average grain yield in 2005 was
The
correlation coefficients of the ten characters of Lima bean evaluated are shown
in Table 4. Number of days to 50% flowering was significantly correlated with
number of main branches per plant, mid leaflet surface area, pod length and
number of seeds per pod. The results indicate that the longer the number of
days to flowering the higher the values of the latter mentioned
characters. Although number of days to
50% flowering had positive correlation with seed yield, it was not significant.
Ariyo (1995) reported positive significant genotypic
correlation between soybean seed yield and days to maturity, but the phenotypic
correlation was not significant. The vegetative characters such as number of
branches per plant, branching height and mid leaflet surface area were
significantly correlated with one another. Inter nodal length was however only
significantly correlated with branching height. Branching height was
significantly correlated with pod length. Branching height and inter nodal
length had positive and significant correlation with 100 seed weight and pod
weight per plant.
Table 4. Pearson correlation
coefficients of 10 agronomic characters of seven Lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.)
local cultivars evaluated at Ile-Ife, Nigeria in 2005 and 2006. |
|||||||||
Characters |
50% Flowering |
Branches per plant |
Branching height |
Inter-nodal length |
Leaflet surface area |
Pod length |
Seeds per pod |
100 seed weight |
Pod weight per plant |
Branches
per plant |
0.62** |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Branching
height |
0.03 |
0.37* |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Inter-nodal length |
-0.27 |
-0.29 |
0.39* |
- |
|
|
|
|
|
Leaf-let
surface area |
0.60** |
0.54** |
0.01** |
-0.18 |
- |
|
|
|
|
Pod length |
0.44** |
0.27 |
0.69** |
0.27 |
0.06 |
- |
|
|
|
Seeds
per pod |
0.49** |
0.53** |
0.29 |
0.21 |
0.28 |
0.41** |
- |
|
|
100 seed weight |
0.21 |
-0.10 |
0.58** |
0.50** |
-0.08 |
0.88** |
0.13 |
- |
|
Pod weight per plant |
0.10 |
0.02 |
0.44** |
0.32* |
-0.15 |
0.66** |
0.36* |
0.61** |
- |
Seed yield per ha |
0.10 |
-0.05 |
0.46** |
0.40** |
-0.19 |
0.71** |
0.31* |
0.73** |
0.98** |
*, **, significant at 0.05
and 0.01 probability levels, respectively |
Pod
length, number of seeds per pod, 100 seed weight and pod weight per plant were
all significantly and positively correlated with one another except that the
correlation between 100 seed weight and number of seeds per pod was not
significant. Seed yield ha-1 had significant and positive
correlations with branching height, pod weight, pod length, number of seeds per
pod, 100-seed weight and inter-nodal length. This result suggests that long
pods, well filled with big seeds could significantly contribute to improved
seed yield in Lima bean. Also the longer the branching height and the
inter-nodal length which are an indication of the length or height of the plant
the higher the seed yield in this crop.
The
results of the stepwise multiple regression showed that three characters, (pod
weight per plant, 100-seed weight and pod length) out of the 10 characters
evaluated were the main seed yield components (Data not shown). The three
characters together accounted for 98% of the variability in seed yield. Pod
weight per plant alone was responsible for 95% of the total variation, this is
understandable as pod weight per plant is a function of number of pods per
plant, pod length and seed size. One hundred seed weight and pod length,
however, only explained 3% and 0.004% of the variability respectively.
The
heritability estimates of the characters are shown in Table 5. Out of all the
characters, 100 seed weight had the highest broad sense heritability estimate
of 98%. The result indicates that
100-seed weight is not significantly affected by changes in environmental
conditions. In a study involving cowpea, 100-seed weight was also reported to
have high broad sense heritability estimate of 96% (Ajibade
and Morakinyo, 2000). Although, pod weight per plant
was the main determinant factor of seed yield, it was only moderately
heritable. Therefore, 100-seed weight is
a better indicator of seed yield in Lima bean; it could then be used as a
selection criterion for higher seed yield. Seed yield could also be selected
for directly since it had moderate heritability estimate of 64%. Characters
such as pod length, mid leaflet surface area, pod weight and inter nodal length
were moderately heritable. Number of
main branches and seeds per pod however, had low heritability estimates.
Table 5. Broad sense heritability estimates of 10 agronomic characters
of seven Lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.)
local cultivars evaluated at Ile-Ife, Nigeria in 2005 and 2006. |
|
Characters |
Heritability estimates (Hb) |
Days to 50% flowering |
0.37 |
Branches
per plant |
0.002 |
Branching
height |
0.22 |
Inter nodal length |
0.33 |
Mid leaflet surface area |
0.40 |
Pod length |
0.56 |
Seeds
per pod |
0.14 |
100 seed weight |
0.98 |
Pod weight per plant |
0.38 |
Seed yield kg ha-1 |
0.64 |
CONCLUSION
In
this study, two lima beans cultivars were identified to produce seed of above
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
R. B. Olowoyo, B Idowu and S. O. Olabode of the Institute of Agricultural Research and
Training, Ibadan, are duly acknowledged for the technical assistance.
LITERATURE CITED
Ajibade S. R. and J. A. Morakinyo 2000. Heritability and correlation studies in
cowpea (Vigna unguiculata
(L.) Walp. Nigerian Journal of Science 15: 29-33.
Apata, D. F. and A. D. Ologhobo 1994.
Biochemical evaluation of some Nigerian legume seeds. Food chemistry 49: 333-338.
Ariyo, O. J. 1995. Correlation and
path-coefficient analysis of components of seed yield in soybeans. African Crop
Science Journal 3 (1): 29-33.
Esquivel, M.; L. Castineiras and K. Hammer 1990. Origins of lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus L.)
in the light of Cuban Materials. Euphytica 49: 89-97.
Fasoyiro S. B.; S. R. Ajibade; A. J. Omole; O. N. Adeniyan and E. O. Farinde
2006. Proximate, minerals and
anti-nutritional factors of some underutilized grain legumes in south-west
Nigeria. Nutrition and Food Science 36
(1): 18-23.
Kay D. E. 1979. Food
Legumes. Crop and Product Digest No. 3.
Tropical Products Institute, Ministry of Oversea Development, London, p. 225-243.
Lyman, S. M; J.P. Baudoin and R. Hidalgo
1985. Lima bean (Phaseolus lunatus) In: Grain Legume Crops. Edited by Summerfield R. J and E. H.
Roberts. Williams Collins Sons & Co. Ltd London United Kingdom. p. 477-519
Morakinyo, J. A. 1996. Heritabilities, correlation and expected responses to
selection of some yield components in grain sorghum (Sorghum bicolor (L.) Moench). Nigerian
Journal of Genetics 11: 48-54.
Nwokolo E. 1996. Lima bens (Phaseolus lunatus
) In:
Food and Feed from Legumes and Oil Seed
Edited by Nwokolo E. and J. Smartt,
Chapman and Hall. p. 144-155.
Rachie, K. O.; L. Song and S. Lyman
1980. Lima beans (Phaseolus lunatus) and
its potentials in the Tropic. In: Advances in Legumes Science. Edited by Summerfield R. J. and A. H. Bunting
Kew: Royal Botanic Gardens. p. 375-381.
Saka, J. O.; S. R. Ajibade; O. N. Adeniyan; R. B. Olowoyo and B. A. Ogunbodede
2004. Survey of under-utilized grain
legume production system in south-west Agricultural zone of Nigeria. Journal of Agriculture and Food Information 6
(2/3): 93-108.
Smartt, J. 1990. The New World
Pulses: Phaseolus species. In: Grain Legumes,
Evolution and genetic resources. Cambridge
University press Cambridge,
p. 85-139.
Página diseñada por Prof. Jesús Rafael Méndez Natera
TABLA DE CONTENIDO DE LA REVISTA CIENTÍFICA UDO
AGRÍCOLA